"The American Jury System is Dying"

U.S. District Judge William G. Young delivered this speech to the Florida Bar Association, stating:


Arbitration is in play. If you trade on the New York stock exchange, have long-distance telephone service, use cell phones, or work for Circuit City or other major employers, he said, you have already given up your right to trial by jury.

“It will never go entirely, but it is already marginalized. It is not at the center of our political discourse. How is this possible, with our Constitution and every one of the 50 state constitutions guaranteeing the right to trial by jury? The general answer is that we do not care.”


When a member of the judiciary stands up and makes this kind of statement, something is going awry; in the case of MBNA and FIA Card Services, these have led to Wrongful Arbitration actions.


About this entry